An FBR test of Inland Revenue officers in Karachi found that no sales tax officer reached the 60% benchmark, and only four income tax officers did. The average score was 26.4% in sales tax and 33.3% in income tax, according to a report cited by The Express Tribune on 14 November 2026. The same exercise will be held for officers in Lahore on Tuesday, 17 November.
The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) says the exercise is a routine “training needs assessment”, not a written test, as reported by Business Recorder.
What the FBR Officers Test Checked
Officers in Grades 17 to 19 who handle sales tax and income tax cases sat an open-book assessment ordered by the FBR chairman. They had to find mistakes in draft orders and explain the legal reasons. The report says it used three cases per tax, so its findings are an initial indicator only.
Karachi Results at a Glance
| Measure | Sales tax | Income tax |
|---|---|---|
| Officers assessed | 150 | 143 |
| Average score | 26.4% | 33.3% |
| Reached 60% benchmark | 0 | 4 |
| Scored below 20% | 47 | 16 |
| Could issue a correct order | 15 | 14 |
| Could review another officer’s draft | 21 | 28 |
Among commissioners and additional commissioners, 4 of 56 in sales tax and 6 of 53 in income tax met the review standard. In 31% of sales tax answers and 24% of income tax answers, officers flagged mistakes that did not exist.
FBR’s Position and Criticism
An FBR official told Business Recorder the exercise identifies training needs, should not be treated as a written test, and that figures circulating on social media “have no basis”. Critics quoted in the same report question the method, the reported use of AI in preparing case studies, and the circulation of officers’ names and scores. They have asked for an independent review.
What It Means for Taxpayers
Adjudication orders decide tax demands, refunds and penalties. If officers struggle to draft legally sound orders, more cases can end up in appeals, which costs taxpayers time and money. The report recommends training in adjudication and drafting, assigning work by competence rather than rank, and a stronger review system for orders. If you receive an order you believe is wrong, you have the right to appeal under the tax laws.

